Share

Blog: Single- or twin-screw extrusion? A crucial decision for snack producers

Blog: Single- or twin-screw extrusion? A crucial decision for snack producers

Extrusion is a well-established process in the snack industry. It has been used for many years to make standard products such as corn curls, onion rings and chipsticks and twin-screw extrusion is increasingly being used for more sophisticated snacks with interesting textures or centre fillings.

 

Simple expanded products

 

Selecting the right extrusion method is trickier: single screw extruders offer simplicity and lower capital cost, but twin-screw extruders provide versatility and higher quality products. This is a fundamental decision with long-term implications, and needs careful consideration.

For companies who foresee a continuing need for relatively small outputs of simple products a single-screw extruder is adequate. But businesses are rarely static, and many single-screw operators are faced with a dilemma when throughput, variety, quality and flexibility need to be increased. Do they add more single-screw machines – adding volume but not value - or switch to twin-screw?

At this point, I know that many do make the switch to twin-screw processing. Potential benefits include the choice of a wider range of ingredients, greater throughput, improved quality, added flexibility, superior process control and lower running costs At this point, I would guess that many are asking themselves why they chose single screw in the first place.

 

Twin-screw extrusion can be used for innovative products, such as sheeted snacks

Both single- and twin-screw extruders generate temperature from mechanical energy, act as a pressurised cook chamber, and define the shape and texture of the product. The contrast between the two extrusion techniques is, however, significant.

With a short barrel and low retention time, single-screw machines offer comparatively poor quality of mixing and heat transfer. Twin-screw extruders - with their intermeshing screw design - create more shear to ensure the ingredients are thoroughly mixed. They also create more pressure, giving a denser and more controllable product at the die. The result is a higher quality snack.

Single-screw extruders are simple to maintain and operate, but can be used to produce only uncomplicated direct expanded snacks using basic formulations, mainly with granular free-flowing materials such as maize grits. Twin-screw extruders process a much wider and more complex range of ingredients including oat flour, starches and fine particle size materials.

I would contend that successful companies must aim to meet a clear demand for attractive, sophisticated products that provide differentiation in a crowded market. Twin-screw extruders, plus a range of post-extrusion forming and cutting technologies, including co-extrusion, can create high-value snacks with an interesting and diverse range of shapes, textures and surface finishes. This is simply not possible with a single-screw machine.

 

Value-added co-extruded products are only possible via twin-screw extrusion

Twin-screw machines provide higher potential throughput, and savings in start and stop procedure, cleaning, and wear. A twin-screw extruder does everything a single-screw can do – and much more. Ambitious, growing companies are choosing twin-screw extrusion as a technology they can rely on as their business develops.

  Single Screw Twin Screw
Relative Cost per Capacity 1.0 1.5 - 2.5
Max Output 100-500 kg/hr 100 - 1,500 kg/hr
Self-Cleaning No Yes - self wiping screws
Mixing Poor Good
Heat Transfer Poor Good
Product Moisture Range % 12 - 35 6 - 50
Raw Materials Granular free flowing Wide range
Wear High Low

Read more:

Baker Perkins' snack extrusion processes

Baker Perkins' SBX Master™ Extruder

Contact Us

   

Contact Form

Office Locations

Baker Perkins Worldwide

Latest News

First day at Gulfood Manufacturing at the World Trade Centre in Dubai! Find us in the Trade Centre Arena on stand S… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

08 November 2022

New divider short hopper design and updated top box reduce long-term cost of ownership: bakerperkins.com/news/new-divid… https://t.co/5Y5rbTPMQV

07 November 2022

Next week, Baker Perkins will be highlighting new opportunities in extrusion-based biodegradable packaging at K 202… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

12 October 2022

Another award! Baker Perkins were sponsors and winners at the third Peterborough Apprenticeship Awards last week:… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

03 October 2022

Our award winning ServoForm Flexi! We are proud to claim the Equipment Innovation award at Confectionery Production… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

15 September 2022

Baker Perkins will be exhibiting at IBIE @BakingExpo at the Las Vegas Convention Center from Sunday, September 18th… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

12 September 2022